Target Circle or Walmart Plus? Here’s What Most Reviews Won’t Tell You
You’ve got two giants in the retail space: Target Circle and Walmart Plus. Both promise savings, perks, and a better shopping experience. But which one actually delivers on those promises? Let’s break it down so you can choose the right one for your lifestyle.
| Feature | Target Circle | Walmart Plus |
|---|---|---|
| Annual Fee | ✗ (Free) | $98/year |
| Free Shipping | ✗ | ✓ |
| 5% Off on Purchases | ✓ (With REDcard) | ✗ |
| Same-Day Delivery | ✗ | ✓ (Select items) |
| Fuel Discounts | ✗ | ✓ |
| Exclusive Deals | ✓ | ✓ |
✅ Target Circle Pros
- No membership fee.
- 5% off with REDcard.
- Exclusive deals and discounts.
❌ Target Circle Cons
- No free shipping options.
- No fuel discounts.
✅ Walmart Plus Pros
- Free shipping on most items.
- Fuel discounts at participating stations.
- Same-day delivery on select items.
❌ Walmart Plus Cons
- Annual fee of $98.
- No percentage discount on purchases.
Performance: Delivery & Shipping
Walmart Plus blows Target Circle out of the water with its free shipping and same-day delivery options. If you’re always ordering last-minute gifts or groceries, Walmart Plus is a godsend. Target Circle, on the other hand, offers no shipping perks unless you’re willing to pay for individual deliveries. So if convenience is your game, Walmart Plus has the edge.
Value for Money
Target Circle is free, which is its biggest selling point. If you’re not keen on annual fees and still want discounts, it’s a no-brainer. However, Walmart Plus offers tangible benefits like free shipping and fuel discounts, which can easily justify the $98/year if you use them frequently. Consider how often you shop and where you spend to decide which is worth it for you.
Additional Perks
With Walmart Plus, the fuel discounts add a nice touch if you’re a frequent driver. Target Circle, meanwhile, offers 5% off with the REDcard, which is perfect for regular Target shoppers. Both offer exclusive deals, but the REDcard feature gives Target Circle a slight edge if you frequently find yourself at Target.
Target Circle’s lack of free shipping is a big downer. Also, the 5% discount is only applicable if you have a REDcard, which not everyone wants. Walmart Plus might sound perfect, but don’t forget that the fuel discounts are only at select stations, so you might not even benefit if you don’t live near one.
Our Final Verdict: Which One Should You Buy?
If you’re a die-hard Target fan who doesn’t like commitment, go with Target Circle — it’s free and the REDcard savings can add up. If you’re more about convenience and speed, especially if you drive often, Walmart Plus is worth the investment. Just make sure the fuel perks are available in your area.
Do I need a REDcard for Target Circle discounts?
Yes, the 5% off is only applicable if you have a REDcard. Otherwise, you won’t get that specific discount.
Can Walmart Plus really save me money?
Yes, especially if you frequently order online and drive a lot. The free shipping and fuel discounts can add up quickly.
Is there a trial period for Walmart Plus?
Yes, Walmart Plus offers a free 30-day trial so you can test it out before committing to the annual fee.
